Doc.
|
Date Docketed
|
Case Type
|
Description
|
Filed by
|
Notes
|
|
02/27/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-DISCRETIONARY JURIS (DIRECT CONFLICT)
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
02/28/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER-NEW CASE-PAY FEE
|
Supreme Court Of Florida BY: Supreme Court Of Florida
|
|
|
02/28/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
PAY CASE FILING FEE-300
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
02/28/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
Fee Paid Through Portal
|
|
|
|
03/05/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-TOLL TIME
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
03/05/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (JURIS BRIEF)
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
03/05/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (JURIS BRIEF-PETITIONER)
|
|
Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted, and petitioner is allowed to and including April 23, 2020, in which to serve the brief on jurisdiction. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
All other times will be extended accordingly.
|
|
04/13/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-CONSOLIDATION GR
|
|
Petitioner's motion to consolidate filed in the above cases is hereby granted and said cases are hereby consolidated for all appellate purposes.
From this date forward, all documents pertaining to the above consolidated cases should be filed electronically through the Florida Courts E-Filing Portal using case number SC20-291 only. (4/15/20- VACATED)
|
|
04/13/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-TOLLING GR
|
|
Petitioner's motion to toll time for filing jurisdictional initial brief is granted and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company shall have to and including April 17, 2020, in which to serve the initial brief on jurisdiction. (4/15/20- VACATED)
|
|
04/14/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (JURIS BRIEF)
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Brief on Jurisdiction
|
|
04/14/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-TOLL TIME
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
Unopposed Motion to Toll Time
|
|
04/15/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-VACATE
|
|
The order of this Court dated April 13, 2020, granting R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company's Motion to Consolidate, and the order dated April 13, 2020, granting R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company's Motion to Toll Time, are hereby vacated.
Linda Prentice's Motion to Dismiss, filed in Case No. SC20-331, is granted, and Case No. SC20-331 is hereby dismissed.
R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Serve Brief on Jurisdiction, and its Unopposed Motion to Toll Time, filed April 14, 2020, are hereby denied as moot. Linda Prentice is currently allowed to and including April 23, 2020, in which to serve the brief on jurisdiction in Case No. SC20-291. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company shall have thirty days after service of Linda Prentice's jurisdictional brief in which to serve a jurisdictional brief in Case No. SC20-291.
|
|
04/23/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
04/23/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
JURIS INITIAL BRIEF
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
PETITIONER'S JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF
|
|
04/23/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX-JURIS BRIEF
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
APPENDIX TO PETITIONER'S JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF
|
|
05/26/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
JURIS ANSWER BRIEF
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
BRIEF ON JURISDICTION OF RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY
**5/27/20: STRICKEN IN LIGHT ON AN AMENDED ANSWER BRIEF ON JURISDICTION FILED ON 5/26/20**
|
|
05/26/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
JURIS ANSWER AMD BRIEF
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
AMENDED BRIEF ON JURISDICTION OF RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY
|
|
05/27/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-BRIEF STRICKEN
|
|
In light of the filing of respondent's amended answer brief on jurisdiction filed with this Court on May 26, 2020, it is ordered that respondent's answer brief on jurisdiction filed with this Court on May 26, 2020, is hereby stricken.
|
|
06/03/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
|
|
06/29/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE OF LAW FIRM NAME CHANGE
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
07/17/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-AMICUS CURIAE INTENT TO APPEAR
|
MR Jesse M. Panuccio 31401 BY: MR Jesse M. Panuccio 31401
|
Philip Morris USA Inc.'s Notice of Intent to File Amicus Brief
|
|
08/11/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-JURIS ACCEPT/BRIEF SCHED (OA LATER DATE)
|
|
The Court accepts jurisdiction of this case.
Petitioner's initial brief on the merits must be served on or before August 31, 2020; respondent's answer brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of petitioner's initial brief on the merits; and petitioner's reply brief on the merits must be served thirty days after service of respondent's answer brief on the merits.
The Clerk of the First District Court of Appeal must file the record which must be properly indexed and paginated on or before October 12, 2020. The Clerk may provide the record in the format as currently maintained at the district court, either paper or electronic.
As jurisdiction has been accepted in the above cause, any movant who wishes to follow through on a previously-filed Notice of Intent to Appear as Amicus or Amici Curiae must now proceed in compliance with Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.370. Oral argument will be set by separate order. Counsel for the parties will be notified of the oral argument date approximately sixty days prior to oral argument.
|
|
08/26/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS)
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO
SERVE INITIAL BRIEF ON MERITS
|
|
08/26/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-TOLL TIME
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
PETITIONER'S MOTION TO TOLL TIME
|
|
08/27/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS)
|
|
Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including September 30, 2020, in which to serve the initial brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
All other times will be extended accordingly.
|
|
09/08/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-APPEARANCE
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Shea T. Moxon 12564
|
|
|
09/30/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
09/30/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
10/07/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RECORD
|
Kristina Samuels 26958 BY: Kristina Samuels 26958
|
1 VOLUME CERTIFIED COPIES OF APPEAL PAPERS - Filed Electronically
|
|
10/07/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RECORD
|
Kristina Samuels 26958 BY: Kristina Samuels 26958
|
1 VOLUME RECORD ON APPEAL (SEALED) - Filed Electronically
|
|
10/07/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RECORD
|
Kristina Samuels 26958 BY: Kristina Samuels 26958
|
VOLUME 2 RECORD ON APPEAL (SEALED) - Filed Electronically
|
|
10/07/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
TRANSCRIPT
|
Kristina Samuels 26958 BY: Kristina Samuels 26958
|
VOLUME 3 TRANSCRIPT- Filed Electronically
|
|
10/14/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS)
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO SERVE
ANSWER BRIEF ON MERITS
|
|
10/14/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-TOLL TIME
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
|
|
10/15/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS)
|
|
Respondent's motion for extension of time is granted, and respondent is allowed to and including November 30, 2020, in which to serve the answer brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
All other times will be extended accordingly.
|
|
11/30/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
ANSWER BRIEF OF RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY
|
|
11/30/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
APPENDIX TO ANSWER BRIEF OF RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY
|
|
12/10/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE
|
MR William W. Large 981273 BY: MR William W. Large 981273
|
|
|
12/10/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS
|
MR William W. Large 981273 BY: MR William W. Large 981273
|
|
|
12/10/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE
|
MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152 BY: MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152
|
|
|
12/10/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS
|
MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152 BY: MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152
|
|
|
12/10/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX
|
MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152 BY: MR Geoffrey J. Michael 86152
|
|
|
12/11/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR
|
|
The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Philip Morris USA Inc. is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondent. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae was filed with this Court on December 10, 2020.
|
|
12/11/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR
|
|
The motion for leave to file brief as amicus curiae filed by Florida Justice Reform Institute is hereby granted and they are allowed to file brief only in support of respondent. The brief by the above referenced amicus curiae was filed with this Court on December 10, 2020.
|
|
12/21/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-TOLL TIME
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
12/21/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS)
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
12/22/2020
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS)
|
|
Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including January 29, 2020, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
|
|
01/25/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
|
MR Philip Morris USA Inc. BY: MR Jesse M. Panuccio 31401
|
MOTION TO ALLOW AMICUS CURIAE PHILIP MORRIS USA INC. TO PARTICIPATE IN ORAL ARGUMENT
|
|
01/26/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS)
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
01/28/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS)
|
|
Petitioner's motion for extension of time is granted and petitioner is allowed to and including March 1, 2021, in which to serve the reply brief on the merits. Multiple extensions of time for the same filing are discouraged. Absent extenuating circumstances, subsequent requests may be denied.
|
|
03/01/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
REPLY BRIEF-MERITS
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
*STRICKEN 3/3/21. Exceeds word limit*
|
|
03/01/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-BRIEF PAGE ENLARGEMENT
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
03/01/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-ATTORNEYS FEES
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
03/01/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
STRICKEN 3/22/21 in light of Amended Appendix filed.
|
|
03/02/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RESPONSE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO PETITIONER'S MOTION TO EXCEED THE WORD LIMITATION FOR THE REPLY BRIEF ON THE MERITS
|
|
03/03/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-BRIEF PAGE ENLARGEMENT GR
|
|
Petitioner's "Motion to Exceed the Word Limitation for the Reply Brief on the Merits" is hereby granted in part. The brief filed with this Court on March 1, 2021, is hereby stricken. Petitioner is allowed to and including March 23, 2021, to file an amended reply brief on the merits which does not exceed an additional 7,000 words in length.
|
|
03/11/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RESPONSE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO MS. PRENTICE'S MOTION FOR APPELLATE ATTORNEYS' FEES
|
|
03/19/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
REPLY AMD BRIEF-MERITS
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
03/19/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
APPENDIX-MERIT BRIEF
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
|
|
03/24/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
REQUEST-ORAL ARGUMENT
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
|
|
03/30/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-OA SCHED (PREV ACCEPTED)
|
|
Amicus Curiae Philip Morris USA Inc.'s Motion for an additional ten minutes of oral argument time is here by denied.
The Court previously accepted jurisdiction. The Court will hear oral argument at 9:00 a.m., Wednesday, June 2, 2021.
A maximum of twenty minutes to the side is allowed for the argument, but counsel is expected to use only so much of that time as is necessary.
NO CONTINUANCES WILL BE GRANTED EXCEPT UPON A SHOWING OF EXTREME HARDSHIP.
|
|
04/19/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-COUNS PRO HAC VICE (FOREIGN COUNSEL)
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Michael A. Carvin
|
|
|
04/19/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
PAY PRO HAC VICE FEE-100
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
Michael A. Carvin
|
|
04/20/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE GR (FOREIGN COUNSEL)
|
|
The motion to appear pro hac vice filed in the above cause by Michael A. Carvin, on behalf of R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, is hereby granted and counsel's payment of the $100.00 fee required by section 25.241(2)(a), Florida Statutes (2015), was received by this Court on April 19, 2021.
|
|
04/20/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-APPEARANCE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Michael A. Carvin
|
|
|
05/17/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-ADDRESS CHANGE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Troy A. Fuhrman 985211
|
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS OF COUNSEL
|
|
05/19/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
|
|
06/02/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORAL ARGUMENT HELD
|
|
|
|
06/03/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
|
|
06/04/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-STRIKE
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Celene H. Humphries 884881
|
PETITIONER'S MOTION TO STRIKE RESPONDENT'S
NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES
|
|
06/04/2021
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RESPONSE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Troy A. Fuhrman 985211
|
RESPONDENT'S OPPOSITION TO PETITIONER'S MOTION TO
STRIKE RESPONDENT'S NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL
AUTHORITIES
|
|
03/17/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-ATTY FEES DY (J/M/O)
|
|
FSC-OPINION: Petitioner's motion for attorneys' fees is hereby denied.
|
|
03/17/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
ORDER-MOTION/PETITION DY AS MOOT
|
|
Petitioner's motion to strike Respondent's notice of supplemental authorities is hereby denied as moot.
|
|
03/17/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
DISP-APPROVED
|
|
FSC-OPINION: We approve the First District's decision in the case under review, to the extent it is consistent with this opinion. We disapprove the decisions of the Second, Third, and Fourth Districts in Duignan, Chadwell, and Burgess, to the extent they are inconsistent with this opinion. It is so ordered.
|
|
04/01/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MOTION-REHEARING
|
PT Linda Prentice BY: PT Thomas J. Seider 86238
|
Petitioner's Motion for Rehearing
|
|
04/18/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
RESPONSE
|
RS R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company RJR BY: RS Marie A. Borland 847984
|
RESPONDENT R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY'S
RESPONSE TO PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR REHEARING
|
|
05/17/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
DISP-REHEARING DY
|
|
Petitioner's Motion for Rehearing is hereby denied.
|
|
06/09/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
MANDATE
|
|
|
|
06/10/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
PUBLISH FULL
|
|
Opinion issued March 17, 2022.
|
|
06/10/2022
|
Direct Conflict of Decisions
|
PUBLISH FULL
|
|
Order re: attorney's fees with concurring opinion issued March 17, 2022.
|