Home Justices Public Information
Doc. Date Docketed Description Filed by Notes
04/26/2001 NOTICE-DISCRETIONARY JURIS (DIRECT CONFLICT) Allstate Indemnity Company AIC BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539
05/02/2001 JURIS INITIAL BRIEF PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 (ORIG & 5)
05/02/2001 APPENDIX PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 (ORIG & 5)
05/03/2001 Case Filing Fee 2001 - 994413 Amount: $250
05/03/2001 Fee Paid in Full
05/21/2001 **MOTION-WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: WE Elizabeth K. Russo 260657 AND SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL--RUSSO PARRISH APPELLATE FIRM TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL AND PHILIP D. PARRISH, P.A. BE SUBSTITUTED AS COUNSEL
06/05/2001 MOTION-COUNS SUBSTITUTION RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877 NOTICE OF FILING WRITTEN CONSENT OF CLIENTS FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL PURSUANT TO RULE 2.060(I) OF THE JUD. ADM. RULES OF FLA PHILIP D. PARRISH.
06/08/2001 MOTION-EXT OF TIME (JURIS BRIEF) RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877 (AMENDED & AGREED MOTION FOR EXT.)
06/13/2001 JURIS ANSWER BRIEF RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Henry A. Seiden 0436763 ORIG & 5
06/15/2001 MOTION-STAY (PROCEEDINGS BELOW) PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 WITH APPENDIX ORIG
07/16/2001 ORDER-COUNS WITHDRAWAL GR THE LAW FIRM OF RUSSO PARRISH APPELLATE FIRM AND PHILIP D. PARRISH, P. A. ARE GRANTED LEAVE TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL AND THE LAW FIRM OF PHILIP D. PARRISH, P. A. TO BE SUBSTITUTED AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR RESPONDENTS
07/16/2001 ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (JURIS BRIEF-RESPONDENT) & RS ANSWER BRIEF ON JURIS FILED 06/13/2001
07/18/2001 ORDER-STAY PROCEEDINGS BELOW GR IN DCA & CIRC COURT-BROWARD PENDING DISPOSITION OF THIS CAUSE
08/08/2001 NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY Allstate Indemnity Company AIC BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 0&5
09/25/2001 ORDER-OA&BRIEF SCHED/JURIS ACCEPTED SENT TO WEST 10/03/2001
09/25/2001 ORAL ARGUMENT CALENDAR
10/12/2001 MOTION-EXT OF TIME (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS) PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 (TO 10-31-01)
10/18/2001 ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS)
11/02/2001 INITIAL BRIEF-MERITS PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 0&7
11/09/2001 APPENDIX PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 0&7
11/14/2001 RECORD/TRANSCRIPT (1 VOLUME & 1 ENVELOPE)
11/19/2001 MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE MR United Policyholders BY: MR William F. Merlin 364721
11/19/2001 ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE GR UNITED POLICYHOLDERS IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS
11/20/2001 MOTION-EXT OF TIME (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS) RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877
11/21/2001 ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Henry A. Seiden 0436763 0&7 (DISK)
11/21/2001 ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS)
11/28/2001 MOTION-AMICUS CURIAE DA2 Florida Justice Association BY: DA2 Richard A. Barnett 257389 AFTL IN SUPPORT IN SUPPORT OF RESP.
12/07/2001 RESPONSE PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 OBJECTION TO FLA. TRL. LAWYERS' MOT. TO FILE A. C. BRIEF
12/07/2001 AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS MR United Policyholders BY: MR William F. Merlin 364721 0&7 (DISK)
12/10/2001 AMICUS CURIAE ANSWER BRIEF-MERITS DA2 Florida Justice Association BY: DA2 Richard A. Barnett 257389 0&6 (DISK) TO BE AMEND IF ACCEPTED--TABLE OF CONTENTS IS INCORRECT; NO STATEMENT OF THE CASE; SOA,;ARG.; AND A CERT OF COMPLIANCE MUST BE INCLUDED (STRICKEN)
12/20/2001 ORDER-AMICUS CURIAE DY ACADEMY OF FLORIDA TRIAL LAWYERS
12/26/2001 MOTION-EXT OF TIME (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS) PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539
12/26/2001 MOTION-ATTORNEYS FEES RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877 0&7
12/28/2001 ORDER-EXT OF TIME GR (REPLY BRIEF-MERITS)
12/31/2001 RESPONSE PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 0&7
01/14/2002 REPLY BRIEF-MERITS PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 (O&7)-DISKETTE
03/05/2002 ORAL ARGUMENT HELD
04/05/2002 NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877 0&7
08/19/2002 NOTICE-SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 (O&7)
03/14/2003 NOTICE RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Henry A. Seiden 0436763 (OF CHANGE OF FAX NUMBER)
12/08/2003 NOTICE-ADDRESS CHANGE PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 OF DAVID B. SHELTON
01/12/2004 MOTION-STAY (VACATE) RS Joaquin Ruiz BY: RS Philip D. Parrish 541877 FILED AS "MOTION TO LIFT STAY" (O&1)
01/26/2004 RESPONSE PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 TO MOTION TO LIFT STAY
01/29/2004 ORDER-OTHER SUBSTANTIVE GR Respondent's Motion to Lift Stay is hereby granted and proceedings in the District Court of Appeal, Fourth District, and in the Circuit Court of the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in and for Broward County, Florida are no longer stayed. The case should be allowed to proceed with respect to all discovery other than the discovery which is the subject of this appeal.; 02/16/04: CORRECTED ORDER
02/10/2004 MAIL RETURNED ORDER DATED 01/29/04 TO HENRY A. SEIDEN - ADDRESS CORRECTED AND REMAILED
02/10/2004 MAIL RETURNED ORDER DATED 01/29/04 TO WILLIAM F. MERLIN, JR. - ADDRESS CORRECTED AND REMAILED
02/10/2004 MAIL RETURNED ORDER DATED 01/29/04 TO MARY E. KESTENBAUM - ADDRESS CORRECTED AND REMALIED
02/13/2004 MOTION-OTHER SUBSTANTIVE PT Allstate Indemnity Company, BY: PT David B. Shelton 710539 FILED AS "MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION OF ORDER DATED JANUARY 29, 2004" (O&7)
04/07/2005 DISP-QUASHED & REMANDED For the foregoing reasons, we quash the decision of the district court and remand the case for further consideration consistent with the principles articulated herein. We also clarify and, to the extent necessary, recede from our decision in Kujawa as explained herein and adopt the rule of law articulated within this decision for addressing the discoverability of documents in first-party bad faith actions.
04/29/2005 MANDATE CC: COUNSEL
04/29/2005 RECORD/TRANSCRIPT RETURNED Hon. Marilyn Nemzura Beuttenmuller, Clerk BY: Hon. Marilyn Nemzura Beuttenmuller, Clerk 1 VOLUME AND 1 ENVELOPE
05/10/2005 ORDER-ATTY FEES GR & REMANDED (PARTY PREVAIL - M/O)
07/14/2005 ARCHIVES